Monday, October 8, 2012

The Good, The Bad and The Wiki

Okay, I read the readings for the Wiki posts and was mildly impressed with the concept of sharing with others in real time. Someone across the state or across the world can see an update seconds after you click the save button. I'm not sure how useful that feature is for the media center, but wikis in general can definitely be useful tools if the media specialist has the time and desire to initially set it up.

In the media center, I could see a wiki being used to share feedback about books, movies, magazines or websites. Reports could even be assigned by teachers and submitted on the wiki. A book report could include a picture of the cover, a brief summary of the story and the reaction of the reader. This kind of wiki would allow other students to read the summary and review to determine if they might like the book themselves. 

For elementary schools, wikis are most likely to be utilized by teachers. They are a great way to store information for classes in a way that the teacher can access it from any computer with internet access. Grade levels may also choose to have a shared wiki that allows all teachers from that grade to edit content and add additional information.

Alternately, teachers may choose to have a wiki page just for his or her own class. Last year, my child's kindergarten teacher had a class wiki. She had a section for pictures and videos of the kids in class, what homework was assigned each night, a discussion section where parents could write comments or make requests for things about the class and a page where she posted what was covered in class for the week. She updated her wiki often and it was a great way to keep parents informed about the progress of the class as a whole.

In middle school, students are a bit more proficient with a computer and may be ready to have access to manipulate a webpage such as a wiki. Links to subject-specific wikis containing research sources can be placed on the desktops of computers in the classroom or in folders on the desktop of the computers in the media center. If each grade had a folder, students would be able to quickly find the wiki they need, use it and complete their assignment quicker that if they had to search for research sources on their own. I still believe, however, that students need to develop research skills as well with print sources and online sources alike. I don't want wiki pages making research too easy for students. The sources on a wiki need to be limited and students required to seek out other sources for the assignments as well.

For high schools students, wikis can be very useful. They can help students share ideas and information.I would like to see each grade level having a wiki to use to share educational information. My mind immediately jumps to all the negative uses that students could find for a wiki. Gossiping, bullying, profanity, lewdness and misrepresentation  have no use in a school sponsored webpage, therefore, student wikis would have to be closely monitored by a faculty sponsor. 

2 comments:

  1. I think you hit on a lot of possible issues with Wikis. Two concerns I share are 1) making sure they are updated and 2) making sure they are monitored. These two things are similar, but have small differences.

    For the classroom wiki at the elementary level, I think they are useful if a teacher is really going to make sure to update them weekly if not daily. Nothing would be more frustrating for a parent to use an out dated site. I think it would be a great idea to have parents add to the content with pictures and maybe even connect it to some projects where parents could post stories for their children.

    However, they must be monitored. Just like you pointed out at the high school level, you do not want bad stuff to show up on your Wiki. I can see where neglecting it for even a moment could cause issues. I can see parents using it to vent and students using it to bully.

    So... if a teacher has the time to update and to monitor, setting up a Wiki could be a great tool for the classroom!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your blog title. From my experience I think wikis would be best suited for teacher use. I haven't used them with students, but I can only imagine the amount of helicoptering you would have to do to make sure everything is appropriate. If I were to implement a wiki, I would do one for my subject area teachers. It would be very useful to have, for example, a 7th grade language arts wiki. We could share lesson plan ideas and other resources for use in the classroom.

    ReplyDelete